Designed to Care - Renewing the National Health Service in Scotland
Executive Summary

   

The Government’s Vision

1. The Government’s vision is a National Health Service for the people of Scotland that offers them the treatment they need, where they want it, and when: a modern, “designed” health service putting patients first. We want a seamless health service centred on primary care, designed to ensure that patients receive care quickly and with certainty. This White Paper sets out how we will achieve these objectives.

2. The Government will ensure that the NHS remains true to its historic ideals, free at the point of use, funded through general taxation and available to all on the basis of need. This Government were elected with a clear mandate for change - a mandate to change the NHS for the better. We will deliver the commitments which won us the support of the Scottish people, and do so in ways which recognise the distinctive needs of Scotland. These have been long reflected in the structure and organisation of our health services, and we shall build on them. To do so is entirely in keeping with the traditions of the past, but also acknowledges that the creation of a Scottish Parliament is intended to ensure that in the future Scottish solutions are found to suit Scottish circumstances.

3. The NHS has stood the test of time for 50 years. In designing our proposals to renew and modernise the NHS in Scotland, the Government intend to lay the foundations for a service which is fit for the next 50 years. The speed of change in scientific knowledge and medical technologies, and the potential offered by modern information and communication systems require the NHS to be ready to embrace change. Instead of lurching from one major reorganisation to another, we need to embrace evolutionary changes, paced and researched, building on what we have.

4. It is sometimes argued that the NHS cannot cope with the pressures it now faces and the challenge posed by the pace of change. The Government reject that view. We will enable the NHS in Scotland to meet the pressures of the future and continue to provide a comprehensive range and quality of health care services through our commitment to annual real increases in resources for the NHS in Scotland, together with its capacity to find newer and more efficient ways of delivering services. In addition, the NHS in Scotland is well-equipped to make medical decisions based on patient need. Our medical culture is based on clinical judgements in which we distinguish between competing demands on the basis of need. As a result, we have a system which reduces unnecessary investigation and treatment. The Government are committed to enhancing this culture. We must root out inefficient and ineffective clinical procedures, subject new drugs and therapies to painstaking analysis in terms of their clinical and cost-effectiveness, eliminate inefficiencies that result from bureaucracy and address the differences in the availability of health care which re-inforce inequalities.

5. Our vision is to build on the strengths we have in the NHS in Scotland and to tackle some of the existing shortcomings which are of concern to patients and NHS staff alike. We want an NHS concentrated on improving health and reducing health inequalities. Scotland is at, or close to the bottom of, the international health league table in the key areas of coronary heart disease and cancer, and people in other European nations enjoy a significantly longer life expectancy than the people of Scotland. While the NHS must continue to target these key areas, real improvements in public health will only be effected by tackling the variations in health status between social groups and between different parts of Scotland. We will publish a Green Paper aimed at establishing a collaborative approach between the NHS and the agencies whose decisions on housing, unemployment and poverty directly affect Scotland’s health.

6. We want a service which is designed from the patient’s viewpoint, which delivers clinically-effective care and which does so quickly and reliably in high-quality facilities. We want a world class health service, available throughout Scotland when people need it. In our renewed NHS, a wider range of information on health, health services and treatment will be available to patients. They will have local access to teams of health care professionals working together, able to obtain specialist expertise when needed, because family doctors and hospital staff are part of a network of integrated clinical services which deliver seamless care.

7. We believe our vision is shared by staff in the NHS in Scotland. We intend to create a health service where staff are free to concentrate on the task to which they are most committed - the delivery of high quality care.

8. To deliver this vision, the Government have concluded that a partnership approach based on co-operation, not competition, is the way ahead for Scotland’s Health Service. A market-style NHS has failed patients; it set doctor against doctor, and developed two-tierism allied to bureaucracy, although to a lesser extent in Scotland than elsewhere. We will retain the benefits of devolved management and retain distinctive roles for Health Boards and Trusts in a patient-focused service built on partnership. Our approach will bring people together to meet the needs of patients by developing 4 main partnerships:

  • a partnership between the Government and the people of Scotland, reflected in the Government’s pledge to continue with annual real increases in NHS funding;
  • a partnership between patients and the professionals who care for them, by giving both a bigger say in the design and management of the NHS in Scotland;
  • a partnership between different parts of the NHS in Scotland to promote the integration of care and provide patients with a seamless service;
  • a partnership between the NHS in Scotland and other organisations whose work can help improve health and the quality of services to patients.

9. There have always been differences in the way the NHS is organised in the different parts of the UK to take account of different needs. But sometimes, changes have been made in Scotland to reflect changes in England rather than in response to specifically Scottish needs. The NHS will continue to provide a common service throughout the United Kingdom, but the advent of the Scottish Parliament will mean a Scottish NHS more finely tuned and more rapidly responsive to Scottish needs.

10. The NHS in Scotland will be one of the main responsibilities of the Scottish Parliament. It will be for the Scottish Parliament to decide the details of its relationship with health bodies, including funding arrangements. Devolution provides an opportunity to build on the strengths of the NHS in Scotland, as well as on the Scottish tradition of community responsibility for those needing care. For example, services can be organised to take account of the range of differing needs, from those of major cities to those of remote and island communities. The new system outlined in this White Paper lays the foundations for the work of the Scottish Parliament in improving the health of the Scottish people now and for future generations.

11. The Government believe the proposals in the White Paper will result in an NHS in Scotland designed to put patients first, better equipped to take advantage of new technology to improve clinical effectiveness and the reliability of clinical care, and better able to develop distinctive solutions to Scotland’s health needs and to provide better value for money. It will keep faith with its founding ideals by delivering comprehensive services to promote good health, rapid diagnosis and treatment for those who are ill, and care for those with continuing needs, and it will be funded through general taxation so that nobody need worry about the cost of being ill.