SEA Review findings

SEA Review front cover

This review of SEA is the first full consideration of the efficiency and effectiveness of the processes and practices within Scotland.

The Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) led and authored this review, in association with Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) and Historic Scotland and with the support of Scottish Government. It was also informed by a project steering group of wider partners and stakeholders.

The report summarises the main conclusions and sets out recommendations for improving the efficiency and effectiveness of SEA process and practice in Scotland.

The review had two key objectives:

Environmental protection and improvement

To identify the extent to which SEA helps to achieve effective environmental protection and improvement and sustainable development by integrating environmental considerations into the preparation of plans, programmes and strategies (PPSs) in Scotland.

Better regulation

To identify opportunities for improving and/or streamlining the SEA processes and practices to make it more efficient and proportionate for those undertaking SEAs or being consulted on them.

In considering these objectives, the review also covers a number of cross cutting issues such as:

> the coverage and usefulness of guidance;

> the role and performance of the statutory Consultation Authorities (CAs);

> how stakeholders and the wider public are engaged in the process.

Main Report

Downloadable document:

main reportmain report [PDF, 3505.5 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Report summary

Downloadable document:

summarysummary [PDF, 1299.0 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 1 - project specification

Downloadable document:

App 1App 1 [PDF, 166.6 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 2 - limitations

Downloadable document:

App 2App 2 [PDF, 138.3 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 3 - literature Review

Downloadable document:

App 3App 3 [PDF, 420.0 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 4 - stakeholder workshops

Downloadable document:

App 4App 4 [PDF, 53.5 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 5 - casework analysis

Downloadable document:

App 5App 5 [PDF, 344.2 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 6 - surveys - introduction

Downloadable document:

App 6App 6 [PDF, 211.9 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 7 - survey monkey - in house practitioners

Downloadable document:

App 7App 7 [PDF, 567.9 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 8 - survey monkey - consultant practitioners

Downloadable document:

App 8App 8 [PDF, 549.0 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 9 - survey monkey - plan makers

Downloadable document:

App 9App 9 [PDF, 306.1 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 10 - survey monkey - general

Downloadable document:

App 10App 10 [PDF, 374.4 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help

Appendix 11 - Bibliography

Downloadable document:

App 11App 11 [PDF, 126.5 kb: 29 Jul 2011]
Open | Open in new window
 Viewer Help