Scottish Government

1. Rape

Yes

None made

n/a

n/a

1. Not Proven

1. Indecent Assault
Rape

No

None made

n/a

n/a

1. Not Guilty
2. Not Guilty

1. Abduction, Assault and Rape
Theft

Yes

Crown

Defence

Prostitution; drug addiction

Prostitution

Allowed in full
Allowed in full

1.Not Proven
2.Withdrawn

1. Rape

Yes

Defence

Past sexual history with accused; sexual maturity; mistaken belief in age

Allowed in full

1.Not Guilty

1. Rape

Yes

Defence

Complainer's sexual maturity/sexual experience; consumption of alcohol at time of alleged offence

Partially allowed

1.Not Guilty

1. Rape alt Crim Law Cons Act 1995 s.1

No

Crown

Defence

Sex behaviour with third party; complainer's alleged drug addiction

Sex behaviour with third party; motive for false allegation; past unproven allegations; drug addiction

Allowed in full

Partially allowed

1. Guilty of alternative - Criminal Law
Consolidation Act 1995 s.1

1. Attempted Rape

Yes

Defence

(Application was submitted 3 times)

1s t submission: complainer's sexuality;

2nd submission: complainer's sexuality; virginity

3rd submission: complainer's sexuality

Refused as not relevant to guilt of accused.
Partially allowed.

Judge refuses to consider 3rd submission

1. Not Guilty

1. Rape;
Crim Law Cons Act s.1
Crim Law Cons Act s.6
Crim Law Cons Act s.6
Crim Law Cons Act s.1

No

Defence

Past unproven allegations of sexual abuse; delay in reporting alleged offences; motive for false allegation (financial gain); contraceptive history

Allowed in full

1.Wthdrawn
2.Not proven
3.Not proven
4.Guilty
5.Guilty

1. Rape
Indecent Assault

Yes

Defence

Prostitution; sexual behaviour with accused on same occasion; consumption of alcohol at time of offence; refusal to cooperate with police; frequenting 'red light' area

Partially allowed

1.Guilty
2.Withdrawn

1. Rape

Yes

Crown

Defence

Past sexual history with accused;

Past sexual history with accused; complainer's sexuality; sexual behaviour with third party

Allowed in full
Allowed in full

1. Not Guilty