On this page:

Evaluation of the 12-Month Fixed Penalty Notice Pilot in the Tayside Police Force Area

« Previous | Contents | Next »

Listen

Appendix C: Police officer Survey Results

Statement presented in E-Survey

Disagree/Strongly Disagree (%)

Agree/Strongly Agree (%)

Prior Preceptions of FPNs

Before the introduction of FPNs, the range of options for dealing with antisocial behaviour ( ASB) were too limited.

12%

58%

Before the introduction, I was in favour of introducing FPNs.

15%

60%

Review of FPN Experience

FPNs are an appropriate method to deal with many instances of:

1. Riotous behaviour whilst drunk in licensed premises

32%

49%

2. Refusing to leave licensed premises on being requested to do so

25%

64%

3. Urinating or defecating in circumstances causing annoyance to others

8%

89%

4. Being drunk and incapable in a public place

16%

68%

5. Being drunk in a public place in charge of a child

64%

16%

6. Persisting to the annoyance of others in playing musical instruments, singing, playing radios etc on being required to stop

14%

75%

7. Vandalism

37%

45%

8. Consume alcoholic liquor in a public place

12%

86%

9. Breach of the Peace

12%

71%

10. Malicious Mischief

55%

26%

-----------------

FPNs are difficult to complete.

70%

18%

FPNs save time.

15%

73%

FPNs have resulted in a reduction on ASB.

19%

18%

Most of the FPNs I have issued were to offenders who were under the influence of alcohol at the time of the offence.

14%

78%

Where offenders were under the influence of alcohol, most could be issued a ticket on the street.

15%

59%

Effect on Operational Practice

The training I received was insufficient.

34%

33%

I now feel I have extra discretional responsibility.

22%

40%

Most of the offenders I have given FPNs, I would previously have warned.

52%

23%

Most of the offenders I have given FPNs, I would previously have arrested.

52%

30%

My workload has increased as a result of the introduction of FPNs

51%

11%

I now spend more time dealing with more serious offences as a result of the introduction of FPNs

36%

18%

I now spend more time dealing with the public, as a result of the introduction of FPNs.

34%

19%

Issuing FPNs has had a negative impact on my safety as an officer.

67%

16%

Future Implications

FPNs will result in a long term decrease in ASB.

26%

30%

FPNs will result in a long term increase in ASB.

44%

12%

The current range of penalty fines is appropriate.

42%

38%

FPNs should be extended to the parents of offenders who are under 16.

21%

66%

There are additional offences which should be added to the FPN list.

15%

49%

There are offences which should be removed from the FPN list.

27%

44%

It would benefit other areas, if FPNs were introduced there.

10%

58%

The introduction of new technology to issue and log tickets would be helpful.

7%

63%

[Emboldened items indicate responses less than 25% or more than 75%.]

« Previous | Contents | Next »

Page updated: Monday, February 12, 2007