On this page:

The Impact of ICT Initiatives in Scottish Schools: Phase 3 - Final Report

« Previous | Contents | Next »

Listen

Appendix 2: Staff questionnaire data

This appendix sets out the basic data from the staff questionnaires, using the questionnaires themselves as a framework. It does not include the open-ended responses, which were analysed separately. All figures are presented as percentages and have been rounded to the first decimal point. The data is presented in the order: Primary co-ordinator, Secondary co-ordinator, Primary teacher and Secondary teacher.

Primary co-ordinator questionnaire and responses
n = 52 (all figs in %)

SECTION 1 BACKGROUND INFORMATION AND REMIT

Please tick the appropriate box.

1.1 There were two previous surveys of the Impact of ICT. If you completed a questionnaire in one of the previous surveys, please indicate which one(s):

Yes

No

1998-99

7.7

71.2

2000-01

13.5

71.2

1.2 How long have you held the remit of ICT Co-ordinator?

1-16 years with most holding it for between 1 and 6 years (67.3%)

1.3 a. Has your role of ICT co-ordinator changed significantly since you took it on?

Yes

59.6

No

36.5

b. If ' yes,' - in what ways?

1.4 a. Does your school have a working group/committee for ICT development?

Yes 25%

No 71.2

b. If 'yes' - what are its key activities?

1.5 How many years since you qualified as a teacher ?

0-5

6-10

11-15

16+

1.9

13.5

15.4

69.2

1.6 Gender

Male 11.5

Female 86.5

1.7 a. Do you have any formal qualification(s) in ICT?

Yes 15.4

No 82.7

b. If yes, what qualification(s) do you have?

c. When did you obtain this qualification?

SECTION 2 ICT CO-ORDINATION IN YOUR SCHOOL

2.1 Approximately how many hours per week do you spend on ICT duties?

0-3h

4-8h

9-12h

12+h

61.5

25.0

7.7

0

2.2 What are the most time-consuming activities in your ICT remit?

Please rank five of following activities in their order of time commitment in your ICT workload,

i.e. 1 for the one which you feel takes up most of your time, 2 for the next, etc.

ranked by teachers

1 st

2 nd

3 rd

a. involvement with the school working/planning group on ICT.

3.8

9.6

5.8

b. involvement in a local authority working group/committee on ICT.

not ranked in first three by anyone

c. running/organising staff development activities on ICT.

9.6

11.5

15.4

d. liaising with the local authority on ICT developments and initiatives.

1.9

5.8

5.8

e. passing on information which comes into school about ICT resources.

1.9

15.4

25.0

f. advising on the purchase of hardware.

0

1.9

5.8

g. advising on the purchase of software.

1.9

3.8

7.7

h. advising teachers on how to use ICT in teaching and learning.

32.7

30.8

7.7

i. advising management how to develop ICT management systems.

0

1.9

7.7

j. dealing with computer crashes and other technical problems.

38.5

11.5

7.7

k. Any other ICT responsibility?

2.3ICT training has been made available through New Opportunities Funding ( NOF) and, more recently, the Masterclass Programme.

Please tick as appropriate

a. I have completed ICT training through

NOF

Masterclass

86.5

9.6

b. I am currently undertaking ICT training through

NOF

Masterclass

0

9.6

c. I have signed up for ICT training through

NOF

Masterclass

0

1.9

Please tick as appropriate

d. ICT training is in my/our development plan

Yes

No

78.8

11.5

e. As yet, no plans have been made for me to take ICT training

Yes

No

7.7

25.0

If you have completed training, please answer the following questions. If not, please go to Question 7.

2.4 a. Has your ICT training experience influenced your practice?

Yes 65.4

No 17.3

2.4 b. If yes, in what key ways? ( Please give up to 3 examples.)

a)

b)

c)

2.5a. Was the ICT training appropriate to your identified training needs?

Yes 53.8

No 25.0

2.5b. If no, please explain.

2.6a. Would you like additional training to fulfill your role?

Yes 73.1

No 15.4

2.6b. Please tick to indicate in which aspects of ICT you would like training/staff development.

a. Using ICT as a general teaching tool with pupils.

21.2

b. Using ICT with:special needs pupils;32.7
high achievers;40.4
low achievers.25.0
c. How pupils might use e-mail for educational purposes.

34.6

d. How pupils might use video-conferencing for educational purposes.

55.8

e. The use of authoring software in teaching ( e.g. HyperStudio).

23.1

f. Using the World Wide Web for educational purposes.

19.2

g. Setting up a school intranet.

40.4

h. Specialised learning systems e.g. Integrated Learning Systems ( ILS) in mathematics and/or English.

25.0

i. Managing a school development policy on ICT.

34.6

j. Making/editing movies

48.1

k. Using web authoring software e.g. Dreamweaver

40.4

l. Working with virtual learning environments e.g. Digitalbrain

40.4

m. Anything else?

2.7 An ICT Co-ordinator can be supported in a number of ways. Of those listed below, which three have you found most useful in helping you undertake yourICT remit?

Your main sources of support: Please tick three boxes only

a. Local authority staff.

73.1

h. Professional journals.

7.7

b. staff in associated secondary school.

5.8

i. Publishers' catalogues.

3.8

c. Other colleagues in own school.

50.0

j. Government information on ICT in schools.

5.8

d. Subject teachers' networks.

0

k. Learning and Teaching Scotland.

36.5

e. Staff in Teacher Education Institutions.

7.7

l. Scottish Virtual Teachers Centre ( SVTC).

7.7

f. Conferences and seminars.

25.0

m. The Web/Internet.

36.5

g. Commercial ICT publications, e.g. computing magazines.

5.8

n. Other.

19.2

If other, please specify:

2.8 Policy

Please circle one number for each statement.

Yes

No

Don't know

a. Does your local authority have a written policy for ICT in its schools?

69.2

13.5

15.4

b. Do you have a written policy for ICT in your school?

75.0

21.2

1.9

c. If yes, does it reflect the national initiatives for ICT such as the "Using the Superhighways: ICT and Development Planning" document? (n = 41, gave 'yes')

48.4

36.6

12.2

2.9 Please indicate below the TWO main priorities in your development plan for ICT over the past year, and how well you feel they were achieved.

Please circle one number for each priority.

More or less achieved

Made fairly good inroads

Didn't make much progress

a. various responses to this question

50.0

21.2

9.6

b. various responses to this question

32.7

30.82

5.8

c. Please outline any difficulties you experienced in trying to implement your priorities:

SECTION 3 ICT IN PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE

3.1 Please indicate the stage of development of ICT in your school by circling a number between 1 and 4.

Learning and teaching in the Classroom.

Not yet started

Just started

Established

Well established

a. Securing opportunities for pupils and teachers to access curriculum material directly from CD- ROMs or CDi.

5.8

15.4

34.6

44.2

b. Securing opportunities for pupils and teachers to access curriculum material directly from the WWW.

1.9

15.4

26.9

53.8

c. Setting goals for ICT experiences for all pupils at different stages.

9.6

19.2

36.5

34.6

d. Extending learning opportunities for high attaining pupils ( e.g. after school activities; or use of laptops).

46.2

25.0

25.0

3.8

e. Giving specialist assistance to pupils with learning difficulties.

7.7

23.1

42.3

26.9

f. Enhancing the quality of reports or profiles of pupils' progress and attainment.

13.5

19.2

25.0

42.3

g. Centralising the assessment and testing records of pupils.

26.9

7.7

21.2

44.2

Communicating and working with others outside school.

h. Giving the local community access to school computers or the Internet.

82.7

7.7

3.8

3.8

i. Establishing collaborative projects with pupils in other schools using electronic networks.

61.5

30.8

7.7

0

j. Giving pupils access to subject specialists outside the school.

82.7

9.6

3.8

0

Supporting staff and school development.

k. Putting teachers in contact with other teachers and professionals locally.

32.7

30.8

21.2

9.6

l. Delivering inservice courses for staff in specific professional areas.

13.5

19.2

42.3

23.1

m. Delivering inservice courses on ICT for staff.

0

15.4

50.0

34.6

n. Recording test and exam results as part of the processes of monitoring and review.

15.4

15.4

21.2

46.2

o. Communicating the schools' identity and role in the community and beyond ( e.g. through a WWW page..

50.0

19.2

9.6

21.2

p. Circulating curriculum materials delivered via the school's intranet.

65.4

13.5

11.5

7.7

Any further comments?

3.2 Communications about ICT in the School

How is information about ICT use in schools communicated to the staff in your school?

Please indicate effectiveness by circling a numberon the scale 2-5, where 2is'not very effective' and 5 is 'very effective'.

The percentages under the effectiveness columns are based on the numbers who used each of the systems listed.

Not used %

Not very effective

<-

->

Very effective

a. Informally between colleagues.

0

3.8

30.8

38.5

23.1

b. Through the school's own newsletter.

55.8

34.8

30.4

8.7

4.3

c. As items regularly on the agenda at staff meetings.

11.5

8.7

30.4

39.1

17.4

d. By internal e-mail or electronic noticeboard.

50.0

23.1

23.1

15.4

23.1

e. Through external inputs e.g. in-service.

3.8

22.0

22.0

40.0

20.0

f. Through in-school staff development events.

5.8

18.4

18.4

40.8

24.5

g. On-line help desk for staff

53.8

12.5

12.5

8.3

12.5

h. Other

If other, please explain.

3.3 Does your school have its own web site?

Yes 26.9 No 44.2 Under development 26.9

If 'yes', please give the web address ( URL):

SECTION 4 LOOKING TO THE FUTURE

4.1 Looking to the future, which of these do you consider aspirations for your school, staff and pupils over the next two or three years?

Please circle one number for each statement.

Already well established

Beginning to happen

Likely to be introduced over next 1 to 2 years

Not yet working towards this

No intention of developing this

a. Developing a common vision on the use of computers within our school.

26.9

46.2

23.1

3.8

0

b. Providing all pupils with access to e-mail.

38.5

23.1

25.0

11.5

1.9

c. Providing all teachers with their own e-mail address.

80.8

11.5

5.8

1.9

0

d. Having regular ICT communications with a proportion of our parents.

0

23.1

28.8

44.2

3.8

e. Having a number of modern computers in every classroom.

73.1

17.3

3.8

0

3.8

f. Having most staff trained in a range of classroom uses in ICT.

40.4

51.9

1.9

3.8

0

g. Seeing positive effects of ICT on pupil attainment in curricular areas.

23.1

65.4

7.7

1.9

0

h. Establishing a school intranet

17.3

25.0

23.1

30.8

0

i. Attaining a target ratio of 1 computer per 5 pupils in your school.

19.2

34.6

23.1

21.2

1.9

4.2 Most of our pupils leaving this school have:

Please circle one number for each statement.

Already well established

Beginning to happen

Likely to be introduced over next 1 to 2 years

Not yet working towards this

No intention of developing this

a. regularly used word processing;

96.2

1.9

1.9

0

0

b. regularly used spreadsheets and databases;

34.6

57.7

7.7

0

0

c. regularly used the Internet to:

0

0

0

0

0

i. search for information;

78.8

19.2

1.9

0

0

ii. down-load information;

71.2

32.1

3.8

1.9

0

iii. send and receive e-mail;

36.5

32.7

25.0

5.8

0

d. had experience of video-conferencing;

0

5.8

30.8

57.7

5.8

e. had experience of multimedia;

19.2

44.2

23.1

13.5

0

f. frequently worked on projects which have been strongly ICT-based;

21.2

42.3

23.1

13.5

0

g. accessed information from specialists outside the school.

0

25.0

32.7

40.4

0

SECTION 5 USING ICT GUIDELINES

The SOEID have disseminated the Information & Communications Technology 5-14 National Guidelines (December 2000) to schools.

5.1. Have you experienced any difficulty in implementing the Guidelines in your school?

Yes

28.8

No

57.7

If 'yes', please explain:

5.2 Has the school or authority set out guidelines for staff in the following?

Please circle one number for each statement.

Yes

No

Don't know

a. The ethical and legal considerations ( e.g. licence agreements).

90.4

3.8

3.8

b. The copyright law and its implications.

92.3

3.8

3.8

c. The need to give guidance to pupils on the copyright implications.

71.2

17.3

11.5

d. The importance of security ( e.g. via passwords. to prevent unauthorised access to data or information.

94.2

5.8

0

e. The protection of young people from possible exploitation by others via the Internet.

100

0

0

f. The protection of young people from exposure to unsuitable materials ( e.g. pornography..

100

0

0

g. The suitable and safe use of e-mail by pupils ( e.g. protection of their identity..

86.5

7.7

5.8

h. The Data Protection Act.

84.6

1.9

9.6

SECTION 6 OBSTACLES TO ICT USE

6.1 Please indicate your views on these obstacles associated with the development of ICT in schools.

Please circle one number for each statement.

strongly agree

agree

disagree

strongly disagree

a. Most teaching staff don't see the development of ICT as a priority.

5.8

23.1

53.8

17.3

b. Most teaching staff find difficulty in progressing their skills in the use of ICT.

3.8

50.0

36.5

9.6

c. Not all teachers have a computer at home on which they can develop their skills.

3.8

73.1

19.2

1.9

d. Too many other priorities are competing for staff time and attention.

57.7

40.4

1.9

0

e. There are not yet enough examples of good use of ICT in the classroom to enthuse and interest teachers.

9.6

32.7

46.2

11.5

f. There is not yet enough relevant curricular material available to interest staff.

7.7

26.9

50.0

15.4

g. Insufficient number of modern computers in each classroom.

7.7

36.5

36.5

15.4

h. There is a lack of convenient access to machines.

15.4

26.9

40.4

15.4

i. Incompatibility of the school's ICT equipment with other systems.

11.5

23.1

42.3

13.5

j. Insufficient numbers of peripherals ( e.g. printers, scanners).

7.7

21.2

55.8

15.4

k. Outdated or lack of internal school network.

15.4

23.1

42.3

17.3

l. Weak infrastructure (telephone links, available rooms and space etc).

15.4

36.5

36.5

11.5

m. Network connection procedures are too complex/time-consuming/unreliable.

11.5

30.8

44.2

11.5

n. Not enough technical support is available to me as co-ordinator.

26.9

23.1

34.6

13.5

o. Not enough technical support is available to the teaching staff in their classrooms.

26.9

32.7

25.0

13.5

p. There are too many confusing copyright/licensing regulations.

11.5

36.5

42.3

7.7

q. Not enough school/authority co-ordination of software purchase and availability.

11.5

40.4

36.5

9.6

r. Insufficient funds to use the resources effectively.

15.4

32.7

38.5

11.5

s. There is too little time to preview software.

44.2

46.2

7.7

1.9

6.2

Over the past two years, what has been of most use or benefit to you in fulfilling your remit as ICT Co-ordinator?

6.3 What benefits, if any, have you already seen for pupils and teachers from the introduction of ICT into your school?

a.

b.

c.

7 HAVE YOU ANY FINAL COMMENTS?

THANK YOU FOR GIVING YOUR TIME TO COMPLETE THIS QUESTIONNAIRE.

THE INFORMATION GATHERED WILL BE USED TO SUPPORT SCHOOLS IN THEIR DEVELOPMENTS.

« Previous | Contents | Next »

Page updated: Wednesday, September 14, 2005