Building a Better Scotland: Spending Proposals 2003-2006: What the money buys

Listen

Building a Better Scotland

INTRODUCTION
Building a Better Scotland

Building a Better Scotland outlines our strategy to improve the lives of all the people of Scotland. It describes how resources will be allocated in order to achieve the Executive's priorities. This introductory chapter sets out:

  • a vision for a better Scotland, outlining the key improvements we intend to deliver for the people of Scotland;
  • a set of priorities, based on the five people's priorities for action - health, education, crime, transport and jobs - and two cross-cutting themes - closing the opportunity gap and sustainable development;
  • key service delivery targets to ensure improvements in public services happen; and
  • a statement of how we will allocate our resources to ensure our spending will help achieve better outcomes through better service delivery by focusing on our key priorities.

1. We are laying the foundations for a better Scotland. A Scotland which is prosperous and ambitious. A Scotland where everyone can benefit from the opportunities available, to build a successful, sustainable and healthy life for themselves, their families and their communities. A fairer Scotland, founded on the values of equality and non-discrimination, in which everyone can achieve their full potential and no one is excluded. A Scotland whose modern, dynamic welcoming society defines the image we present to the world.

2. We are clear about what we want for Scotland. A Scotland which is healthier, with lower crime, improved attainment in schools, effective transport services and of course employment for all. Achievement of our desired outcomes will in part depend on others, not just the Executive. We will work with partners in the UK Government, Scottish local government, the public sector, the business community, trade unions and the voluntary sector to help make change happen. The Executive can, and should, lead by example, delivering on its own commitments. To gauge our performance, we have, where possible, described measures of those outcomes and set targets for them - to allow you to see for yourself whether we are delivering on our commitments.

3. We have identified five priorities for action - health, education, crime, transport and jobs. This Spending Review has ensured that our resources are allocated to deliver in these areas. In addition, we recognise the threads running across these priorities, and we have established cross-cutting themes on closing the opportunity gap and sustainable development. These are the issues that matter most to the people of Scotland, and they form the basis for all of our work.

4. Effective public services and good government are essential if these results are to be achieved. Recognising this, we have placed strong emphasis on delivering better public services. To improve the quality of life for everyone in Scotland, whether in our towns and cities or in rural areas, we will target our efforts on improving public services. It is important that the money going into public services produces the improvements that matter to people - like shorter waiting times in the NHS. This depends not only on the amount of money but on how it is used. We have a duty to ensure we deliver best value for every penny of public money we spend.

5. The critical role of delivery on the ground is played by our partners in our schools, the health service, the police and so on. It is those on the frontline who deliver the services that meet people's needs. We are committed to the highest possible standards in public services, and continuing the shared goal of reform and modernisation is therefore central to the achievement of our vision.

6. A summary of the key outcomes we have set for Scotland between now and 2006 is set out in the following table. The full targets are set out in the appropriate section below, and further details of the measurement and monitoring of these targets will be published shortly.

Building a Better Scotland

Health

Education

Crime

Transport

Jobs

Aims

To build a healthy, caring Scotland

To give every child and young person the best possible start in life

To create a safer and fairer Scotland

To promote an accessible Scotland

To create a highly skilled, learning, earning, connected Scotland

Objectives

To work towards a step change in life expectancy for Scots

To enable Scots to enjoy a healthy life

To maximise achievement and attainment

To ensure all children and young people are safe and do not threaten the safety of others

To reduce crime and disorder committed by young people

To promote inclusion and equality

To reduce crime, especially violent crime

To reduce congestion

To improve access to public transport

To promote more sustainable modes of transport

To improve road safety

To raise Scotland's long-term sustainable growth rate

To improve the skills base of Scotland

To boost science and increase innovation

To support a sustainable tourism sector

Measured by

Reductions in death from coronary heart disease

Reductions in death from cancer

Reductions in death from strokes

Reductions in smoking

Reductions in heavy drinking

Increases in the proportion of pupils achieving expected levels of attainment in primary and secondary schools

Reductions in the proportion of pupils failing to reach key levels of attainment at P7, S4 and S6

Increases in the number of vulnerable children receiving a package of integrated support

Reductions in violent crime

Reductions in the number of persistent young offenders

Reductions in fear of crime, or seriousness of worry about crime

Increases in rail passenger journeys

Increases in local bus passenger journeys

Reductions in congestion on our busiest roads

Reductions in serious and fatal road accident casualties

Increases in business research and development in Scotland

Increases in productivity in Scottish industry

Increases in number of people in employment undertaking training

Increases in proportion of graduates in our workforce

Increases in academic and industry ventures

7. In order to change Scotland for the better, these Spending Plans will allow us to invest in infrastructure. We will deliver major improvements through:

  • new and refurbished hospitals with the latest in information technology;
  • the biggest school building plan for a century;
  • investment in housing through stock transfer and the Central Heating Programme; and
  • improvements in road and rail infrastructure.

8. We are investing in our children and young people through improvements in teaching in our schools and by ensuring that school education better equips our young people for the world of work and enterprise. There is also increased support for children and families, especially in the crucial early years. The extension of Education Maintenance Allowances will ensure more young people stay on at school to build confidence and raise attainment. Once they have left school we are extending the highly successful Modern Apprenticeships scheme to ensure over 25,000 places are available to help close the opportunity gap and contribute to improving productivity across Scotland. A key part of our work to improve public health will focus on young people.

9. We are improving the quality of life of Scots by enabling local authorities to target more resources on what matters locally - better schools, well maintained roads, environmental improvements. We will help regenerate communities by making them better places to live and work, and we will continue to tackle crime, including youth and drug-related crime and anti-social behaviour, to create safer communities across Scotland.

Our priorities for action - health

10. We aim to improve Scotland's health, and our health service. We recognise that Scotland has an unacceptably poor health record. The most disadvantaged in Scotland's communities are also those with the most unhealthy lifestyles and the poorest health, hampering their efforts to improve their own situation. That is why we are prioritising health improvement, with a major increase in spending on public health across the Executive.

11. Following the Spending Review, the health and community care budget will increase significantly, with all the additional money available to Scotland as a consequence of increased UK health spending being spent on improving the nation's health and the NHS in Scotland. By 2005-06 this will mean record levels of investment in Scotland's health - keeping our health provision at European levels.

12. While we can be justly proud of the National Health Service, we recognise the need to continue to reform and modernise in order to provide the service that we expect and deserve. The record increases in funding for the NHS provide an exceptional opportunity to modernise the health service and to make Scotland a healthier country.

Our priorities for action - education

13. We aim to give all Scotland's children the best start in life. Access to education and training is the key to unlocking their potential so that all of our children and young people leave full-time education with the skills, knowledge and motivation they need to find employment and live fruitful and rewarding lives. That is why we are investing in our young people to raise attainment and achievement - for example, by improving the quality of teaching and the fabric of our schools. We will continue to support the National Priorities in Education. We will continue to deliver better pay and conditions through the National Agreement, in partnership with local authorities and teachers. Our Public Private Partnership plans will deliver the biggest ever investment in Scottish schools. The new community schools approach and improved school meals will ensure that all pupils across Scotland can benefit from improved health and integration.

14. A child's potential, rather than background or postcode, must be what determines his or her future. Improving life chances for all will require additional support for children and young people with special educational needs, vulnerable children and those with disabilities. We will continue to invest in integrated children's services, ensuring that children and young people receive the support they need. In doing this, we will continue to bring together our policies on education, health and social justice to ensure maximum impact.

Our priorities for action - crime

15. Our aim is to make Scotland a safer and fairer place. Crime and the fear of crime impact heavily on us all, but particularly on the disadvantaged and vulnerable in our communities. If we are to build stronger, more confident communities, then we must make them safer and make them feel safer. That means tackling violence - especially drug-related offences - swiftly and effectively, making our streets safer. Our Ten-Point Action Plan to reduce youth crime will explore the potential for fast-track children's hearings for young persistent offenders, develop proposals for increasing the involvement of parents in preventing their child's offending and will identify the potential for a youth court for persistent and serious young offenders.

16. Two years ago, we made a commitment to increase police officer numbers to record levels by 2002. We delivered on that commitment and our aim is to maintain frontline officer numbers at present levels. Within that total, we will continue to increase the numbers of police officers dedicated to working on drugs trafficking. We will also continue with our agenda to modernise the police service by, for example, encouraging Best Value and securing greater efficiency in common police services. The recently negotiated pay and conditions package for federated ranks (those from constables to chief inspectors) will also play an important part in the reform process.

17. Making Scotland safer means faster prosecutions and more support for the victims of crime. But it also means working with offenders, particularly the young, to reduce re-offending, and tackling the links between deprivation, drug misuse and crime.

Our priorities for action - transport

18. Our aim is an accessible Scotland, with a modern, efficient and sustainable transport system. We all need fast and convenient access to services, particularly those whose transport options may be more limited, including those living in disadvantaged and rural areas. Our businesses need their people, goods and services to be able to travel easily and cheaply across Scotland and out to markets elsewhere. But our transport system must also be sustainable, minimising the impact on our environment.

19. Better, more accessible transport services will allow communities across Scotland to play their part in the country's prosperity, while improving their access to goods and services. The Integrated Transport Fund is the core of our additional support to new public transport ventures which, alongside improvements to the road network such as the A8 and A80 upgrades, will help improve access both within and between our cities and rural areas. Our programme of concessionary fares offers help to those who need it most.

Our priorities for action - jobs

21. Our aim is a highly skilled, learning, earning, connected Scotland. We recognise that we need to do more to match the economic performance of our major competitors. If we are to build a Scotland that provides opportunity for all, and provides high quality public services for those who need them, then we must build a smart, successful Scotland. It also means helping those in the most disadvantaged communities, who can face the greatest challenge in finding work, to find employment. We will make the improvements in infrastructure, in training, in science, in skills, in research and development and in enterprise that will support businesses, make them more competitive and help the economy to grow. As part of that, there will be a significant boost in science spending as a result of the Review.

22. We must ensure that everyone has access to the skills and training that are vital in a modern economy, and that access to further and higher education and training makes lifelong learning a reality for all. We must ensure that entrepreneurship, innovation and ambition are encouraged and rewarded, and that more business growth is encouraged. We must ensure that lone parents in particular have access to good quality, affordable childcare, to enable them to take up education, training and job opportunities. We will extend Education Maintenance Allowances to cover all of Scotland and we will launch an initiative on Education for Work and Enterprise.

23. Our jobs agenda is of course much wider than the work of Enterprise and Lifelong Learning. Business representatives continually cite improved transport and infrastructure links as their top priority, and we have responded in this Review by significantly increasing our investment in these areas. We are also investing in our young people to ensure our education system is attuned to enterprise. And we are promoting tourism, culture and sport. Tourism supports nearly 200,000 jobs in Scotland, contributing 4 billion to the economy. It is a particularly vital source of jobs in many rural and remote areas of Scotland. We will support the sector by implementing the Tourism Framework for Action. We will do this by marketing Scotland as a "must visit" tourism destination through VisitScotland and increasing the resources available to Historic Scotland, the largest operator of paid visitor attractions in Scotland. We will also introduce and fund a new Major Events Strategy, aimed at attracting additional visitors to Scotland throughout the country and throughout the year. If we are successful in our bid with Ireland to host the Euro 2008 Football Championships, we will fund the additional infrastructure needed to host this major event. This would provide a unique opportunity to promote all aspects of Scotland to a world-wide audience as well as providing new jobs. The creative and cultural sector employs 100,000 people, contributes 5 billion to our economy each year, and the digital media area is likely to grow by 30% over the next five years. Sport is also a significant and growing employer and contributes 1 billion to the economy. We are taking forward a range of actions to support these sectors under the National Cultural Strategy and Sport 21 respectively.

Delivering Better Services

24. Achieving our goals requires effective public services and good government. We need responsive public services, firmly focused on the needs of those who use them, which ensure that those who need the most help receive the most help, in a way that meets their needs and expectations. We must have well-run, cost-effective and innovative public services that improve standards while minimising costs and bureaucracy.

Investing for the Future

Better public services depend on having modern, efficient infrastructure in place - delivering the new buildings necessary for innovative service delivery, making sure our roads and other capital assets are properly maintained, investing for the future.

We have already delivered the largest ever hospital building programme, and announced our plans to deliver the biggest school modernisation programme Scotland has ever seen. The Glasgow Stock Transfer will deliver over 1.5 billion of investment over the next 11 years, and transform the lives of tenants and their communities. This Spending Review builds on that investment, including increased funding for the new Integrated Transport Fund to make sure we can deliver a transport infrastructure fit for the demands of the 21st century, and a significant increase in support for waste infrastructure to meet our demanding new recycling targets. Full details of our investment strategy will be published later in the year.

Throughout the Spending Review we have concentrated on delivering best value for money. This means choosing the most appropriate means of investment for each individual case whether through PPP, direct investment, or supporting others to invest on our behalf. We remain determined to further improve methods of delivery and continue to learn from best practice.

25. Effective local government is crucial to the delivery of better services for Scotland's communities. To enable local authorities to focus their efforts on delivery, we have provided the stability of three-year financial settlements. And we are giving them new powers and freedoms: to take action to improve the well-being of their areas; to work together with other agencies; and to invest more in improving services. We will also reinforce Best Value in local authorities by a new statutory duty requiring the pursuit of continuous improvement across all their activities.

26. Those who deliver public services need clear service delivery objectives to work towards and clear targets by which their performance can be measured. The objectives and targets for our five delivery priorities - health, education, crime, transport and jobs - set out over the page will help to ensure high quality and effective delivery across Scotland.

Improving Public Services Objectives and Targets

Health

Education

Crime

Transport

Jobs

Objectives

To minimise waiting at each stage of care

To improve the patient's experience of NHS services

To deliver integrated community care services prioritising those members of society who are in greatest need

To put children, young people and their families first

To establish an effective framework for learning

To promote inclusion and equality

To maintain front line police numbers

To improve public confidence in the justice system

To reduce offending

To ensure we have a safe, integrated, effective and efficient transport system

To maintain and enhance the lifeline links

To encourage and support lifelong learning by widening access to skills opportunities and improving the quality and effectiveness of further and higher education within Scotland

Measured by

Ensuring speedy access to a member of a primary care team

Improving waiting times for outpatient appointments

Limiting the maximum wait for urgent referral for all cancer cases

Ensuring no patients wait more than six months for inpatient or day case treatment

Improving standards of cleaning and infection control

Improving quality of care services

Implementing A Teaching Profession for the 21st Century

Providing 300 either new or substantially refurbished schools

Rolling out the new community school and health promoting school approach across every education authority and over time to every school

Increasing seizures of Class A drugs

Enforcing the law on drugs, and tackling the drugs/crime link

Providing 6,300 prisoner places

Increasing the number of prison programmes and approved activities by 40%

Increasing availability of community disposals

Sustaining improvements in court case times

Increasing availability of support for victims

Increasing the quality and quantity of lifeline ferry services

Improving passenger information through Traveline Scotland

Improving trunk road maintenance

Achieving at least 1.5 million visits to Transport Direct portal per annum by 2006

Increasing air passenger numbers passing through airports operated by Highlands and Islands Airports Limited

Increasing provision of Modern Apprenticeships

Increasing the number of people in employment undertaking training

Closing the Opportunity Gap

27. Across all of our priorities, our aim is to close the opportunity gap between the most disadvantaged and the average for Scotland. Everything we do, every policy we introduce, every decision we make will be measured against success in closing the gap, to ensure that we live in a society founded on fairness, equality and opportunity.

Closing the Opportunity Gap Objectives1

Health

Education

Crime

Transport

Jobs

To work towards a step change in life expectancy for Scots, particularly disadvantaged members of the community, including children and older people

To close the gap in educational achievement between the most disadvantaged children and young people and the average, and promote equality, inclusion and diversity

To reduce crime, particularly violent and drug-related crime and housebreaking, which disproportionately affects disadvantaged areas

To reduce social exclusion by making public transport easier to use, and helping vulnerable and disadvantaged people to access services, employment and leisure opportunities

To close the opportunity gap on employment and learning, breaking the cycle of poverty and working to break down barriers faced by the most disadvantaged

Note
1. How we will measure progress on closing the opportunity gap is set out later.

28. Scotland must be a society of strong, inclusive communities, a society where child poverty is a thing of the past, a society where everyone, young or old, whatever their circumstances, can live with dignity. We will tackle discrimination and inequality and improve the access to services of disadvantaged groups by working to mainstream equality across the Executive and the public sector. This document sets out how we will deploy our resources to achieve these aims.

Closing the Opportunity Gap in Scotland

This Spending Review has enabled us to make major commitments to achieving social justice by:

  • providing the opportunity for childcare places for parents in disadvantaged areas to help them enter or re-enter the employment market;
  • improving the quality of housing that social tenants live in by investing in further stock transfers and housing improvements;
  • supporting the provision of alternative accommodation to replace Glasgow's outdated homeless hostels;
  • tackling anti-social behaviour by investing in neighbourhood wardens and other local initiatives;
  • improving programmes in secure accommodation to help reduce offending and to ensure each young person in secure accommodation can achieve their potential when they leave;
  • making a statutory debt arrangement scheme available to all eligible people burdened with multiple debt;
  • working to secure public confidence, including that of ethnic minorities, in the prosecution system;
  • supporting lone parents. Delivering responsive services - early years intervention, childcare, access to further and higher education, removing barriers to work;
  • investing in the educational attainment of looked after children and supporting these young people when they leave care;
  • ensuring that at least 15,000 vulnerable children under five, every looked after child, every pupil with special educational needs and every child on the child protection register has an integrated package of health, care and education support which meets their needs;
  • reducing the gap between the average attendance levels in schools serving areas of high and low deprivation by 10% by 2006, and by another 10% by 2008;
  • increasing the nutritional value and presentation of school meals and increase take-up, especially among pupils eligible for a free school meal;
  • supporting disadvantaged students and providing additional funding for child care for these students;
  • extending the Education Maintenance Allowance to all of Scotland - ensuring that children from low income families are able to stay on in education beyond age 16;
  • providing training for young people to give them skills to enter the workforce and increasing the number of Modern Apprenticeships to over 25,000, targeting under-represented groups;
  • improving access to services in rural Scotland and maintaining sustainable communities;
  • introducing free off-peak bus travel for elderly people and those with a disability - making it easier for them to travel, improving their quality of life;
  • improving access to cultural and sporting events and activities;
  • improving access to public services and information through the Modernising Government Fund. New technology, such as smart cards, will reduce the stigma from making use of services such as free school meals; and
  • targeting the proceeds of illegal activities such as drug-related crime, which has a major impact in disadvantaged communities.
Sustainable Development

29. Across the whole work of the Executive, our aim is to promote sustainable development, combining economic progress with social and environmental justice. Our policies and service delivery will have regard to the overarching priority areas of resource use, energy and travel. This commitment extends across and beyond the five priority areas, and will also contribute directly to the achievement of targets within the priority areas, for instance by promoting more sustainable and healthier lifestyles.

30. At present, disadvantaged communities suffer further because they live in a poor environment. Our commitment to environmental justice means cleaner, healthier neighbourhoods, improving quality of life, and tackling crime.

Building a Sustainable Scotland

This Spending Review has enabled us to make major commitments to sustainable development in Scotland across the Executive, including:

  • increasing the amount of waste collected by local authorities which is recycled or composted to 25%;
  • building sustainable development into the major school building and refurbishment programme;
  • developing education for sustainable development across the curriculum, including initiatives like the Sustainable Secondary Schools Initiative and Eco-Schools;
  • investing in new social housing to promote sustainable development through the use of renewable materials, better insulation to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, maximising the development of brownfield sites and better land use planning to reduce travel to work distance;
  • building sustainable development into the Glasgow Stock Transfer and other transfers to ensure that our investment produces homes that are warm, dry, energy efficient, safe and secure;
  • setting high performance standards for central heating installed under the Central Heating Programme;
  • inviting a team of independent consultants to assess eight priority business areas in Enterprise and Lifelong Learning for their impact on sustainable development. As a result of this work we are looking at how to take forward, for example:
    • sustainable development in further and higher education;
    • ways in which the Enterprise Networks can measure progress towards sustainable development; and
    • using Regional Selective Assistance to encourage resource use planning.
  • working with the Enterprise Networks to promote growth in clean technology sectors including renewable energy and energy efficiency;
  • helping tourist businesses become more sustainable through the VisitScotland Green Tourism Business Scheme, and access funds for energy-efficient heating systems or waste recycling through the Clean Energy Demonstration Scheme and Loan Action Scotland;
  • managing sustainable forests: Scotland's national forests were among the first in the world to win internationally-recognised independent sustainability certification;
  • supporting the further development of the Greencode Environmental Management Tool and NHSScotland's good record on energy efficiency;
  • delivering better public transport for all sectors of the community, reducing both resource use and the need to travel unsustainably;
  • Modernising Government Fund projects helping to reduce or eliminate the need to travel to access public information, advice or services, for example through contact centres, "one-stop shops" and video conferencing; and
  • promoting sustainable development in the built environment through the Executive's architecture policy - nearly half of UK carbon dioxide emissions are from buildings.
Spending Plans

31. We have made major innovations in the presentation of this document. We report our aims and targets, and what we see as the major service delivery objectives and service delivery targets. All of this is done for a reason - to set out to the public what we want to achieve through our spending and to explain how this will be delivered. We want our expenditure to have maximum impact. We have made a clear commitment to expressing what our spending will achieve and the differences it will make to the lives of the people of Scotland.

32. As we move forward into the new spending period, this emphasis on making clear linkages between our spending and our priorities will become ever stronger, ensuring that our resources are focused more and more tightly on delivering positive change for the people of Scotland.

33. The tables below set out the overall allocations made for each portfolio for the years 2002-03 to 2005-06 for TME (total managed expenditure) in both cash and real terms. We present the material by portfolio since that is the way in which Parliamentary authority for expenditure is sought. Of course, there are many issues that cut across portfolio boundaries. Some, such as closing the opportunity gap and sustainable development, need to be addressed across the whole Executive. Others require several portfolios to work together. For example, new resources to tackle youth crime have been split between the Education and Young People, Social Justice and Justice Portfolios. There are special Ministerial and official arrangements to make sure these cross-cutting issues are tackled in a joined-up way. Several of the most important cross-cutting issues are highlighted in boxes throughout the document, bringing together the contributions from the relevant portfolios and reporting the targets and outcomes portfolios are jointly responsible for delivering.

34. These are firm three-year plans that will not be re-opened until the next Spending Review. For the first time, all numbers in this Spending Review are presented on a full resource basis, which affects the balance between what is shown in DEL (Departmental Expenditure Limits) and AME (Annually Managed Expenditure). This means that the numbers shown for 2002-03 will not be identical to those shown in this year's Annual Expenditure Report (AER). The new basis gives a more accurate assessment of the rate at which resources - in particular capital assets - are being used.

35. The following chapters then set out in more detail what these allocations mean - showing portfolio by portfolio what we will be investing in and what we will deliver in return. Where spending is shown as increasing, for example, by 10/20/30 million, this means that spending in 2003-04 will increase by 10 million, spending in 2004-05 by 20 million, and spending in 2005-06 by 30 million. All spending figures are given in cash terms unless otherwise indicated. More detailed financial information for each portfolio will be included in the detailed Draft Budget Document later in the autumn, which will also include a full reconciliation between the AER and the full resource numbers.

Total Managed Expenditure by Portfolio

m

2002-03
Plans

2003-04
New Plans

2004-05
New Plans

2005-06
New Plans

Justice

742

773

807

832

Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service

63

87

90

92

Education and Young People

219

283

349

368

Tourism, Culture and Sport

199

209

235

254

Health and Community Care

6,596

7,292

7,881

8,586

Social Justice

800

839

921

945

Enterprise, Lifelong Learning and Transport

3,324

3,606

3,798

4,030

Environment and Rural Development

1,089

1,140

1,162

1,189

Finance and Public Services

7,532

8,217

8,589

9,076

Administration

236

242

249

257

Scottish Parliament and Audit Scotland

150

137

88

88

Contingency Fund

20

29

42

142

Total

20,972

22,854

24,210

25,857

Total Managed Expenditure by Portfolio in Real Terms at 2002-03 Prices

m

2002-03
Plans

2003-04
New Plans

2004-05
New Plans

2005-06
New Plans

Average Increase

Justice

742

754

768

772

1.3%

Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service

63

85

85

86

10.7%

Education and Young People

219

276

332

342

16.0%

Tourism, Culture and Sport

199

203

223

235

5.8%

Health and Community Care

6,596

7,114

7,501

7,972

6.5%

Social Justice

800

818

877

878

3.1%

Enterprise, Lifelong Learning and Transport

3,324

3,518

3,615

3,742

4.0%

Environment and Rural Development

1,089

1,112

1,106

1,105

0.5%

Finance and Public Services

7,532

8,016

8,176

8,428

3.8%

Administration

236

236

237

238

0.3%

Scottish Parliament and Audit Scotland

150

134

84

82

(-18.2)%

Contingency Fund

20

28

40

131

Total

20,976

22,296

23,044

24,011

4.6%

Page updated: Wednesday, April 05, 2006