Listen
Agricultural subsidy appeals
10/09/2007
An independent review group is to be set up to investigate concerns over how agricultural subsidy appeals are processed.
Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs Richard Lochhead has appointed John Kinnaird, former president of NFU Scotland, as chair of the new body which is charged with reviewing the appeals process and ensuring its clarity. The review group members will include representation from outwith the agricultural industry.
Mr Lochhead said:
"We made a manifesto commitment to review the controversial agricultural subsidy appeals process as there is a widespread concern over the operation of the current system.
"Since taking office, I have been reflecting further on the operation of the current appeals systems and on its results.
"The existing system was introduced in November 2000 following consultation held in December 1999 which drew responses from a wide range of industry interests. The primary objective of the appeals process was to ensure a fair and independent appeals procedure which complied with the European Convention on Human Rights and which was accessible to all farmers who felt that the Government had not reached a correct decision on their subsidy claims.
"While the system was broadly welcomed at the time, there has been disquiet about how it operates and it is time it was reviewed.
"I am well aware that many farmers feel they are treated like criminals for making what they claim are innocent mistakes with their claims. There is also a widely held view that the penalties can be disproportionate to the offence. Although the Scottish Government must comply with existing EU regulations in relation to subsidies, I am keen for the review group to explore the issues surrounding the current appeals system and to propose appropriate changes.
"I welcome John Kinnaird as chairman of review panel and intend to make a more detailed announcement in due course over the body's remit and the appointment of independent scrutineers."
It is anticipated that the panel will consult with the industry to hear their views on the operation of the current system. The panel should make recommendations by 2008.